Tuesday, 11 February 2014

DotCom bets: they just got more complicated.

iPredict has a contract that pays $0.10 for every 1% of the vote earned by the yet-to-be-formed Kim DotCom Internet Party. The contract's price then is the market's expectation of the party's vote share.

But not anymore.
We now have a ridiculously complicated contract. Here's what you're trading on, if you're buying this contract.

So, what the hell should you pay for a contract that pays $0.10 for every 1% of the vote earned by the yet-to-be-formed Kim DotCom Internet Party?

Let's label a few terms and make a few guesses. 
  • Pp is the probability that there is a Party, say 0.8.
  • Ps is the probability that DotCom really would kill the party if it doesn't poll 5% prior to the election, say 0.75
  • Vh is the expected vote share conditional on a poll result of 5% prior to the deadline
    • This one's hard to ballpark. You could make an argument for pegging it lower than 5% because a single outlier poll could be sufficient for his going ahead. But I expect that the state of the world in which he can get a single >5% figure is the state of the world in which we've had substantial GCSB revelations affecting NZ; in that state of the world, I'd put even odds on 5%. And so I'll stick it at 5, or $0.50 in iPredict prices.
  • Vl is the expected vote share conditional on no polling result of 5% prior to the deadline.
    • I'll peg this at 0.5%. If he goes ahead despite no polling result above 5%, credibility's shot. And it's also the state of the world in which there's no substantial GCSB revelations. So $0.05 in iPredict prices.
  • Pt is the probability that the Internet Party polls at least 5% prior to the deadline.
    • I'll peg this at at even odds IF we get substantial GCSB revelations during the election campaign, and nil otherwise. Supposing even odds on substantial revelations, that gives us 25%.
The expected value of the contract is then:

Pp*[[Ps*[(Pt*Vh)+((1-Pt)*0)]+[(1-Ps)*[(Pt*Vh)+((1-Pt)*Vl)]]]

Using my rough ballpark estimates, that's then:

0.8*[[0.75*((0.25*$0.5)+0)]+[0.25*[0.25*$0.5+0.75*$0.05]]]
= 0.8*($0.09375+.25*$0.04375)
= 0.8*$0.1375
= $0.11

2013

These were some of my favourite posts of 2013. I've grouped them somewhat. You should read all of them if you haven't already. And read them again if you have.

Fun economics
  • A rather neat field experiment. Want to know whether increased immigration and diversity scares the ex ante population? Run an experiment. 
  • Inequality, crime, and jellybeans. Inequality may be linked to some stuff. But beware the multiple comparisons problem.
  • Don't start by assuming stupidity. Or, why petrol excise beats fuel efficiency mandates.
  • Guaranteed income and living wages. If unemployment makes people pretty unhappy, and it does, then salary subsidies beat wage mandates.
  • Rent extraction: Quebec edition. Why campaign finance rules don't work well.
  • Shirking air traffic controllers. If you want to make flying riskier, just let air traffic controllers use deteriorating performance, as measured by number of breaches of minimum separation guidelines, serve as indicator of stress sufficient for triggering paid stress leave. 
  • It is forbidden except where it is compulsory. On the nonsense of Canada's cartel legislation. Some cartels are illegal. Other cartels are mandatory. 
  • A simple argument in favour of polygamy. The division of labour within the household is limited by the number of spouses. Why not allow more spouses?
  • Coase and dorm-room noises. U Auckland's student dorms considered banning loud sex late at night. A 'fence-out-the-noise' solution is plausibly better. And what if some neighbours actually got utility from the noise?
  • A modest proposal for internet tax parity. Sure, there are some distortions caused by that low-value imports are GST-free. But if we really want a level playing field, it isn't enough simply to put GST on all imports. I have a plan....
  • Hunt it to save it. Tweeting and shaming rich folks who pay exorbitant fees for safari hunts can do harm to conservation.
  • Currency risk: Why do we make international students bear the risk of fluctuating exchange rates? 
  • Tax all the things. Sure, it's a bit distortionary that firms don't pay Fringe-Benefit tax on parking spaces. But don't we need to consider all the distortions? Shouldn't there be tax credits when an employer compensates you with pay for bearing a disamenity?
  • Career lesbians. The lesbian-heterosexual wage gap illustrates what's behind the gender wage gap: having kids, time outside of the workforce, and post-kid shunting towards non-pecuniary benefits. And, employer fears of prospective maternity risk.
Crunchy, crunchy data
  • Trusting secret data: Dunedin edition. The Dunedin longitudinal survey has the country's best longitudinal data set all hidden away due to privacy considerations. But it would be simple to make it open access, if they wanted to. Simply run a GSS-style front end while keeping each individual's data confidential at the back. 
  • Minimum wages and climate change. Why do so many who accept the science on climate change not accept the science on minimum wages, and vice-versa?
  • The price of wool and economic growth. Remember the big Reinhart-Rogoff controversy? Much of it hinged on a single cell in an Excel table. Here's the story of that cell, and the data wonks who understood how the New Zealand waterside lockout mattered.
Health, fiscal externalities, and the nanny state.
  • Tax maximisation, smoking, and the Stalin Gap. In which I explain what happens when we start considering it an externality on the State and other taxpayers that you've not earned what you could have earned had you chosen less leisure. How else can we interpret the "lost productivity" costs of smoking?
  • The Social Costs of Healthy. In which we discuss whether we even have the sign right in all these discussions of the fiscal burden of lifestyle choices.
  • Coroner recommends. New Zealand would be rather different if government implemented all of the daffy coroner recommendations.
  • No, you can't tax your way to happiness. Some parts of the happiness literature suggest that you can be made better off by taking away some choices. But there are problems....
  • DTC prescription drug advertising. Bans on drug advertising don't make much sense, and make even less sense in New Zealand.
  • Blind to others' ends. Paternalistic policy ignores the very legitimate ends sought by those subject to the regulation.
  • Liquor traps. Be careful how you run liquor permits. It's pretty easy to get into transitional gains traps. Wellington City Council needs to pay attention on this one. When Admiral Akbar-Tullock shouts "It's a Transitional-Gains Trap!", you should listen.
  • Our manufactured drinking crisis. In which the Ministry of Health's data pretty clearly shows that there's no increasing problem with problem drinking. 
  • Social costs and HPV. When we start taking fiscal externalities as having policy consequence, well, we might need to start taxing oral sex. And that's just the start.
  • You have got to be freaking kidding me. Mandatory helmets for scooters? How the hell did any of us survive childhood before the nannies came to protect us? A few anecdotes of the things we survived, back in the day....
  • Driving while.... Lots of things impose risk on other drivers that's comparable to the risk that comes with driving in the .05-.08 range. Should we ban driving at 4 am?
  • Keeping it 18. There was no particular increase in bad stuff after New Zealand reduced the alcohol purchase age to 18. Worse, typical RDD methods used in the US to estimate the bad stuff that could happen were they to reduce their drinking age to 18 more likely identify a birthday effect than anything likely to persist long after the birthday.
  • On alcohol, I now have a standard disclaimer.
Earthquakes and policy
  • EQNZ Lesson 1 for Wellington: Fix EQC. EQC has proven utterly unable to handle the Christchurch mess. There's time to change the system before Wellington gets its earthquake. Here's how to start. 
  • One block of Estuary Road. In which I chronicle the wonderful post-EQNZ fun in my neighbourhood.
  • Oh Christchurch. It didn't have to be like this. But post-EQNZ Christchurch does provide a nice illustration of the problems of central planning.  
New Zealand
  • Kiwi Freedom. NZ is the best country in the world over a plausible bundle of economic and personal liberties. 
  • So where the bloody hell are ya? In which I again argue that libertarians should move to New Zealand.
  • Boffin fun. Suppose that you're the official in the Minister of Culture's office who gets the letter from some European heavy metal website asking how heavy metal music is supported in New Zealand. And suppose further that you have some understanding of the difference between Nightwish and Dimmu Borgir. And that you have a sense of humour.
Other good stuff:
Your favourites of 2013, as ranked by pageviews:
And, finally, a few other posts that got a lot of +1s but aren't otherwise here indexed:
  • If it scares, it leads. In which I'm annoyed by anti-GMO reporting.
  • Dairy Stooges. If you put a 245.5% tariff on cheese, but allow low-tariff import of ready-made pizzas, guess what happens? Go on, guess.
  • Living Free. I still expect that the Human Freedom Index provides a better proxy for experienced freedom than the World Values Survey.
  • I'm scared, Dave. Google provided me an involuntary partial lobotomy when they excised Google Reader.
  • McDonald's vs McWorld. What happens when the only ethnic cuisine you can't get anywhere in the world is the country-specific McDonald's offerings?
  • Obesity and mortality revisited. Yes, the morbidly obese die earlier. But those who are merely overweight live longer. So why do we keep hearing obesity numbers that combine the obese with the overweight? To fuel the perception of an obesity crisis demanding action and policies and regulations and, perhaps, sweet sweet research grants for the public health squad.
The National Business Review reprinted many of these posts as part of their online weekend edition this year. Some of those are indexed here, but their tagging isn't comprehensive. I also started The Dismal Science feed at SciBlogs, the blogging forum of the Royal Society's Science Media Centre.

Analytics tells me that about 68,000 unique visitors made 133,000 visits to Offsetting for 193,000 pageviews in 2013; SiteMeter tells me we had 140k visits. Either way, thanks for dropping by!

Monday, 10 February 2014

Trans-Tasman sad

The weekend news told me that Kiwi fire fighters are helping put out bush fires in Australia.

It also tells me that Australians hate Kiwis so much that they've pressured their two main supermarkets to stop stocking New Zealand produce. This isn't some voting thing where nationalism is cheap at the ballot box and so people vote for Buy (insert home country name here) mandates. Supermarkets in Oz expect to profit because their customers are just that nationalistic.

C'mon, Bruce, give your head a shake. Autarky is stupid.

Update: vengeance is always tempting. But, it's generally misdirected.
First off, the Australian banks are hardly to blame for whatever the Australian supermarkets are up to.

Second, the Australian supermarkets are doing it because they think that their customers really want it. So taking it out on the New Zealand franchises of Australian supermarkets might make those supermarkets run a broader profit and loss calculation, but it will likely just punish the local franchisees while not addressing the underlying problem: nationalism's popularity in Australia.

Third, autarky hurts everybody, but is most painful for the country imposing it on itself. Doing it to ourselves in revenge makes as much sense as bashing ourselves in the head with a hammer to get back at our neighbour for doing the same thing.

It mightn't be nuts* for the New Zealand government to suggest merging its government-run, stupidly nationalistic, generally pointless, blame-the-Greens-for-it "Buy Kiwi Made" campaign with the Australian private-sector equivalent for a Buy ANZAC logo, perhaps timed for the Gallipoli centennial next year. Even better would be abandoning all of these kinds of autarkic sentiments.

* Note the "might" here. Basically we get pretty quickly into the whole trade-diversion literature. It can be better, from an efficiency perspective, to have nationalistic Aussies put the same "not Australian" discount on all foreign goods and then to maintain the proper mix of imports within the smaller set of imported things than to have NZ within the "Counts as Australia" circle and so to distort trade. I still lean in favour of "diminish nationalism by making more countries count as "us" for nationalistic purposes", and reckon that arguments against having the merged ID would also be arguments in favour of abandoning the Australian-NZ free trade area, but arguments going the other way are tenable.

Friday, 7 February 2014

All joy no fun? You're failing.

Parenting is only "all joy and no fun" if you decide to run things that way. It's totally up to you. If you like that kind of thing, well, de gustibus. But know that it doesn't have to be that way, and especially so if all the doomsayers have put you off having kids.

Things we've done that make parenting fun.

  • The kids never got to see any TV shows we don't like so they don't ask for them. They get to choose among TV shows we do like. The Wiggles have never entered our house. We don't have Sky with insipid Disney cartoons. Instead, the kids get:
    • Classic episodes of Sesame Street
    • Animaniacs
    • Pinky and the Brain
    • Adventure Time
    • PowerPuff Girls
    • Samurai Jack
    • Classic Bugs Bunny
    • Freakazoid
  • The kids never get cutesy kid music that we don't like. They can choose among the things we do like. And, I spend time finding music that we'll all like. Like Dan Marcotte's brilliant Dungeons & Dragons kid-friendly tunes. My daughter demands "Jello Music" sometimes when we're driving. What's Jello Music? This is Jello Music. Songs sung by Jello Biafra. The kids love Weird Al Yankovic. Why oh Why are you listening to The Wiggles?
  • We buy books to read to them that we also like reading. Our son started into illustrated versions of The Hobbit, The Odyssey, and the Ring Cycle before he was 4. There are TONS of books that are great for both parents and kids. Shaun Tan works great. We've almost finished Eddings' Belgariad series. 
  • Audiobooks while commuting can be great too. StoryNory.com has, for free (donation recommended), great audio renditions of:
  • We play games with them that we also enjoy playing. You can totally run Dungeons & Dragons scenarios that work for 3 year olds if you don't expect that they'll be writing things down on their character sheets. Set up simple puzzle quests and see how they work them out. What could be more fun than that? They beg for me to run scenarios while we're commuting to and from daycare/school. Because of bad traffic, I sometimes have to turn down my childrens' pleading requests that we play Dungeons and Dragons in the car. My children have excess demand for Dungeons and Dragons. What could be better?
    • For a few months, when he was 5, the boy's favourite thing in the whole world was to play Skyrim with me. I'd play, he'd watch for monsters and point out things I should be doing. All joy, all fun. Then, when we'd go out to the park afterwards, we'd LARP Skyrim. He'd set up an alchemy table on a stump and we'd find things to mix together. Then we'd kill monsters with sticks. So long as you don't care about looking ridiculous, it's awesome. And ceasing caring about what other people think about stuff is a great general purpose technology anyway.
    • We've been playing 2-player Lego Batman. The three year old is almost old enough to handle a controller - I give it another couple of months. She's ridiculously good at solving some of the puzzles and giving advice as her brother and I go though. 
    • If he's good, I'll play Pocket Minecraft with him as LAN play. And if he saves up enough money from doing chores around the house, he'll be able to buy PC Minecraft for the machine in the living room. 
    • If you've forgotten how to have fun playing LEGO, are you sure that kids are right for you in the first place?
Yes, the first year's insomnia is awful. Toilet training is horrible. Feeding can be a disgusting mess. There's much tedious training required if you want to produce kids that others might find acceptable adults later on. But the fun stuff should be fun for both of you. I don't get people who decide to kill the fun stuff. What a horrible horrible pointless and stupid waste. There are little people in your house who would love to play Dungeons and Dragons with you, if only you would give them a chance.

Folks like Ruth Graham need to ignore all the whiny parents. A lot of it is just signalling from people who think that others will hold them in higher esteem because of all of the work they've put into parenting. Don't encourage this labour-theory-of-value-thinking by sympathising or awarding approbation. Read Bryan Caplan's serenity approach to parenting and have fun.

    Tuesday, 4 February 2014

    Lockean Parking

    In the Lockean framework, private property can be appropriated from the commons through the mixing of labour. If you mix your labour with the untilled soil, leaving as much and as good yet for others to till, then that tilled soil is yours. You have homesteaded it.*

    And so we come to parking spaces in snowy places. Normally, you appropriate a parking spot by putting your car into it. All available spots are up for grabs. Because cities refuse to charge market-clearing prices for parking, there's excess demand that's solved by first-come-first-served queueing.

    But suppose you've had a snowstorm. None of the parking spaces are available because they're all snowbanks. When you shovel out a spot, you have homesteaded it. At least a little bit. You've mixed your labour with the uncleared snow and have some ownership right to that space, at least for a little while. Standard practice in many North American cities then allows the clearer of the space to own it and to signal ownership by the leaving of an appropriate marker. A chair, a road cone, a barrel - something big enough to say "Hey, I cleared this spot. I know you could move the barrel and take my spot, but you'd be a total jerk if you did."

    The Boston Globe tells me [HT: @BKDrinkwater] that this practice has even been recognized in official city practice [I don't know if it's a bylaw.] If the city declares a snow emergency, you can set out a marker owning a space for 48 hours after the end of the snow emergency. So you get a limited homesteading right. But the city's practice doesn't put in a homesteading requirement.

    And so we can get problems where the state comes in to enforce a pre-existing social norm through official practice. What if you declare a snow emergency, and it doesn't snow? By the city's rule, you can then appropriate any old parking spot without having mixed your labour with it. Or can you?
    [Mayor] Walsh said he supports the concept of the earned spot. “If you use manual labor to get your car out, I think for 48 hours, a couple days, you can have it,” he said. But last week, after the forecast fizzled, Walsh said “there was clearly no need for saving spaces after that storm.”
    Still, many did, especially in South Boston, where residents report being locked in by the system: Whether they agree with the idea or not, if they don’t put one out for themselves — even with no snow on the ground — it would simply mean they have no place to park. So people like Ivaska [earlier dubbed Captain Cone] and a man named Dan Bothwell went on a tear around the neighborhood, tossing everything they found in a parking spot. “I call it my Winter Olympics,” said Bothwell, 37.
    “People say to me, ‘Why do you get so mad?’ ” he said. “I say, ‘Because it’s not a South Boston parking issue, it’s a common sense issue. If you get 12 inches and you shovel your spot, you get it for a day. But everybody hates people who abuse it, yet they won’t be an adult and move the cone if they need to park. If something happens to your car, you go to their house.’ ”
    The situations can get famously tense. Already this winter, punches have been thrown and nail guns used to shoot out tires. “I hope I’m wrong, but I honestly believe something bad will happen to someone soon. It’s out of control.”
    The mayor said that he sees no problem with people moving markers from spots if a person has not shoveled — “That’s not an earned spot,” he said — or if they’re past the 48 hours, and he has a particular peeve with people who put them out before the first flakes fall.
    “You can’t put it on blacktop,” he said. “To me, that’s not grounds for saving a space. That’s not how I grew up.”
    The streets are empty now, but storm fever will arrive again, and so will the early space-savers. Captain Cone is not betting on common sense.
    I love the induced prisoner's dilemma. I also love that it takes an entrepreneur to initiate the revolution. Everybody fears retribution so nobody wants to be first mover against the norm-breaker, and because everybody else fears that the game unravels, they all put out space savers. Until Captain Cone comes around, pushing everybody back to the better equilibrium.

    You could likely write a political economy masters thesis on social norms around this issue: how the institution evolved in different cities, how it interacts with city practice - whether parking wardens leave the cones there or biff them, and what happens when code conflicts with norm.





    * Cat has homesteaded nothing [very mildly NSFW].

    Minimum Wages

    The NBR asked me about John Key's proposed hike to the Minimum Wage. So I told them:
    New Zealand’s minimum wage is among the world’s highest, when we consider it in relation to the median wage. American minimum wages vary state-to-state, but the federal minimum wage of $7.25 is about 40% of median hourly wages in the US; ratios in individual states vary with state-by-state wages and minimum wages. The latest New Zealand Income Survey has median hourlyearnings at $21.58, so a $13.75 minimum wage is about 64% of the median wage. I get nervous about disemployment effects of the minimum wage when the minimum wage is more than half the median. If we want to support the working poor, targeting assistance through wage subsidies like Working For Families can do the job without forcing low-skilled workers out of the workforce.
    The PM cited numbers that were close to the true ones and that got the important bit right: there is a very large gap between American and Kiwi minimum wages when we consider them in terms of the median hourly wage. A $15/hour or $18+/hour minimum wage would be a pretty bad idea.

    I wasn't saying we should make WFF more generous. But if you want to do more for the working poor, wage subsidies still beat minimum wages. I've seen some complicated arguments around complementarity between minimum wages and wage subsidies, but it's hard to avoid that very high minimum wages do damage to the employment prospects of our least skilled, that the poor are more likely to be the customers of the products and services provided by minimum wage workers and consequently bear more of that burden, and that the tax system is a more equitable way of distributing the burden of helping the working poor if we think it is a good thing that the working poor be paid more.

    I suppose it's also relevant that Obama wants a substantial hike to the US minimum wage. A dark side of me wants him to do it, just so we can get some clean estimates of just how bad the disemployment effects would be. Some states would have to hike a lot to hit a much higher US minimum; others, not at all. But the social costs of such experiments can be large. If you want to make sure that poor workers have more money, run it through EITC instead of minimum wages. I know there've been a few recent surveys getting reasonable support among economists for a hike to the US minimum wage, but that, I think, is largely because they've written off the prospects of doing it through EITC or other wage subsidy schemes. Why not try for the first best, if those are your values?

    Monday, 3 February 2014

    Ron Weasley sucks

    Finally. JK Rowling's admitted what readers of Yudkowsky's continuum have long known: Ron Weasley sucks. Well, she didn't quite put it that way - she said instead that Hermoine should never have wound up with Weasley. Which is true, because Weasley sucks.

    In Harry Potter and the Methods Of Rationality, Potter was trained in the methods of science and rationality before discovering magical Britain. And so he decided to approach magic scientifically to see how it worked. Great fun.

    Here's how Yudkowsky's continuum dealt with Weasley. Harry meets him in Chapter 7. We don't hear from him much after that. Which is as it should be.
    "Cor," said the red-haired boy, "are you really Harry Potter?"
    Not this again. "I have no logical way of knowing that for certain. My parents raised me tobelieve that my name was Harry James Potter-Evans-Verres, and many people here have told me that I look like my parents, I mean my other parents, but," Harry frowned, realising, "for all I know, there could easily be spells to polymorph a child into a specified appearance -"
    "Er, what, mate?"
    Not headed for Ravenclaw, I take it. "Yes, I'm Harry Potter."
    ...
    [After Ron explains Quidditch]: "So let me get this straight," Harry said as it seemed that Ron's explanation (with associated hand gestures) was winding down. "Catching the Snitch is worth one hundred and fifty points? "
    "Yeah -"
    "How many ten-point goals does one side usually score not counting the Snitch?"
    "Um, maybe fifteen or twenty in professional games -"
    "That's just wrong. That violates every possible rule of game design. Look, the rest of this game sounds like it might make sense, sort of, for a sport I mean, but you're basically saying that catching the Snitch overwhelms almost any ordinary point spread. The two Seekers are up there flying around looking for the Snitch and usually not interacting with anyone else, spotting the Snitch first is going to be mostly luck -"
    "It's not luck!" protested Ron. "You've got to keep your eyes moving in the right pattern -"
    "That's not interactive, there's no back-and-forth with the other player and how much fun is it to watch someone incredibly good at moving their eyes? And then whichever Seeker gets lucky swoops in and grabs the Snitch and makes everyone else's work moot. It's like someone took a real game and grafted on this pointless extra position so that you could be the Most Important Player without needing to really get involved or learn the rest of it. Who was the first Seeker, the King's idiot son who wanted to play Quidditch but couldn't understand the rules?" Actually, now that Harry thought about it, that seemed like a surprisingly good hypothesis. Put him on a broomstick and tell him to catch the shiny thing...
    Ron's face pulled into a scowl. "If you don't like Quidditch, you don't have to make fun of it!"
    "If you can't criticise, you can't optimise. I'm suggesting how to improve the game. And it's very simple. Get rid of the Snitch."
    "They won't change the game just 'cause you say so!"
    "I am the Boy-Who-Lived, you know. People will listen to me. And maybe if I can persuade them to change the game at Hogwarts, the innovation will spread."
    A look of absolute horror was spreading over Ron's face. "But, but if you get rid of the Snitch, how will anyone know when the game ends?"
    "Buy... a... clock. It would be a lot fairer than having the game sometimes end after ten minutes and sometimes not end for hours, and the schedule would be a lot more predictable for the spectators, too." Harry sighed. "Oh, stop giving me that look of absolute horror, I probably won't actually take the time to destroy this pathetic excuse for a national sport and remake it stronger and smarter in my own image. I've got way, way, way more important stuff to worry about." Harry looked thoughtful. "Then again, it wouldn't take much time to write up the Ninety-Five Theses of the Snitchless Reformation and nail it to a church door -"
    And the best part: after Ron tells Harry to tell Draco to go away:
    Harry counted to ten inside his head, which for him was a very quick 12345678910 - an odd habit left over from the age of five when his mother had first instructed him to do it, and Harry had reasoned that his way was faster and ought to be just as effective. "I'm not telling him to go away," Harry said calmly. "He's welcome to talk to me if he wants."
    "Well, I don't intend to hang around with anyone who hangs around with Draco Malfoy," Ron announced coldly.
    Harry shrugged. "That's up to you. I don't intend to let anyone say who I can and can't hang around with." Silently chanting, please go away, please go away...
    Ron's face went blank with surprise, like he'd actually expected that line to work. Then Ron spun about, yanked his luggage's lead and stormed off down the platform.
    "If you didn't like him," Draco said curiously, "why didn't you just walk away?"
    "Um... his mother helped me figure out how to get to this platform from the King's Cross Station, so it was kind of hard to tell him to get lost. And it's not that I hate this Ron guy," Harry said, "I just, just..." Harry searched for words.
    "Don't see any reason for him to exist?" offered Draco.
    "Pretty much."
    The whole world anxiously awaits the arrival of Chapter 102. I will provide no further spoilers. But if you thought that Ron Weasley sucked, you really need to read HPMOR. Start with Chapter 1.