Around the traps

A few bits I've neglected to blog.

• My chat with Adam Jarvis on datacentres. 
• A follow-up chat with RCR on the same thing, as well as a couple of bits on the India Free Trade Agreement. 
• The RBNZ's Keeping Cash Local consultation was just atrocious. The Bank threatened commercial banks via a consultation document. OIAs showed that the Bank knew it did not have the power to  just go ahead and do what it threatened to do. There ought to be an inquiry on how that consultation document got out the door. My submission on the debacle. And my piece at Newsroom.
• Bit at The Post on some very fun AI textual analysis quantifying cultures of innovation going back over a thousand years. 
• The UK's Andy Burnham promises more localism, and the policy document looks decent! My piece at The Herald.
• Treasury knows the ethnicity of 97.5% of its staff; the remaining 1.5% didn't answer the question. By contrast, Treasury does not know what proportion of its staff have qualifications in economics. And it earned a big red "weak" grade on the quality of its economic analysis in the latest PIR. My piece in The Post. I also chatted with Sean Plunket about it. 
• And, over at Newsroom, a bit on the coming FSANZ rules that add more new NZ-Australia labelling requirements for alcohol. I thought that National had promised that we were going to stop doing this and shift instead to QR codes on store shelves to make it easier to enable imports and new grocer entry. 

Afternoon roundup

Closing the tabs so I can find the ones I really do need...

• Using hoards of ancient coins to trace out historic trade networks
• Left-wing populism is also risky
• ACT won't be supporting National's proposed social media age limits
• Meanwhile, Meta and Google battle over who's going to be stuck trying to verify user ages. I really don't like options that require OS-level ID verification.
• NZ needs more investable propositions
• "It will come back to bite you", but if partisans have very high discount rates....
• BBC's More or Less on the relative risks of vaping and smoking
• Happy 50th Birthday to the Layfield Report. I'm still unconvinced of the merits relative to a combination of user/beneficiary charges, uniform general rates, and land-value apportionment of council rates. I'll have to properly go through the thing though. 
• I'll be helping out on the Advisory Group for Te Kura Taka Pini. 

Afternoon roundup

The closing of the browser tabs:

• The Commerce Commission blocks NZ DJ software company Serato from selling out to Japanese DJ product company AlphaTheta. One lesson: don't do tech startups in NZ if your exist strategy is selling out to a larger company.


• New Zealand's bureaucrats have apparently been considering a harmonised set of plain packaging rules on infant formula with Australia, which would force an important part of dairy processing overseas. Hopefully the government stops this one while issuing a pretty hard "please explain" to the officials involved. 


• Aaron Smale's reporting on the Inquiry into Abuse in Care has been superb throughout, and is great again this morning at Newsroom. He asks the right questions about state accountability. I expect that those who helped cover up the state's abuses are more likely to earn knighthoods than to face charges. 


• Gas shortages have Huntly importing more coal. 


• The Department of Conservation has more opportunity than any other part of govt I can think of to realistically improve its own finances through user charges and concession auction. Newsroom reports this morning that they're facing "huge financial pressure". There is an obvious solution here.

Morning roundup

A selection as I read through the morning papers.

• Twenty-three MPs claim an accommodation allowance to stay in their own Wellington properties.  Well, consider the alternatives, which the story doesn't.
  • You could pay all MPs much higher salaries and tell them to sort their own accommodation, which would mean higher effective pay for Wellington-area MPs who wouldn't need to pay for a second residence.
  • You could means-test access to accommodation support which would basically scale MP pay by prior wealth. It would also tilt things to discourage candidacy of middle-to-higher wealth MPs from outside of Wellington.
  • You could raze Premier House and put up halls of residence for MPs and the Prime Minister (and maybe have a reality show based there).
  • Or you could provide non-Wellington MPs who have a Wellington property with a strong incentive to sell off any Wellington properties by not providing the payment to MPs who don't live in Wellington but who have a house here.
  What do you think sucks least? Because I'm not sure there are other options.


• The Government is to run a Parliamentary inquiry into rural banking.

  The Federated Farmers’ campaign for an inquiry was led by farmer Richard McIntyre.
  “I have been inundated with phone calls and emails from farmers, and even some former bankers, wanting to tell their stories,” he said.
  “And there’s been some pretty harrowing stories.”
  The worst of those involved farmers losing farms that their families had owned for generations, he said.

  Parliament might consider whether difficulty in foreclosing on failing farms, because of this kind of response, provides a strong disincentive to lending on rural properties.


• I love that Xero is now putting out productivity data. The data is depressing. But great that Xero's doing it!


• My gawd people. We have a competitive electricity market. New supply can come in if demand increases - though we need to make consenting for it easier. Emissions from mining and from electricity are in the Emissions Trading Scheme. If you want fewer emissions, reduce the number of unbacked units the government will issue or allocated between now and 2050. But wanting to block a gold mine because it will use energy and might have CO2 emissions is nuts.

Afternoon roundup

A closing of the browser tabs:

• New Zealand's space industry keeps growing. Here's BusinessDesk on Dawn Aerospace. So neat. 
• America's economists are very sceptical about the latest round of tariffs on imports from China.
• Ancient bugs hiding in NZ amber.
• Statistics New Zealand is shifting out of central Auckland because of increasing levels of 'intimidating behaviour' in the neighbourhood. Police victimisation stats had a surge in crime in Auckland Central West in 2023 that's since abated, but the number of victimisations there remains far higher than in the Lambton area around the SNZ Wellington office. 
• Easy to find claims that public ownership is better than private because private operators are too short-term oriented. Meanwhile, half the board of Christchurch City holdings has resigned. Why? "...the decisions council has subsequently taken over 2024 to maximise short-term dividends at the expense of paying down group debts and investing in the future of its companies has caused us to lose confidence in council's ability to responsibly own core strategic infrastructure."
• Satya Marar at Mercatus on America's populist turn in antitrust policy. 
• Modern desalination is pretty cheap. The energy required for desalinating a household's water is roughly on par with the power needed for its refrigerator.
• Whenever you're depressed by NZ problems like deteriorating council infrastructure, messes in government IT systems, and crises in public media funding, always worth checking over at Canada's seemingly worse problems in the same areas.
• Concrete is neat.
• There is no good version of a central bank digital currency.
• Eli Dourado wants floating cities.
• Worried about the de-banked - people who can't reasonably access normal banking serives? Fix AML.
• If I were still teaching Public Choice, this would be added to the syllabus. If you want the implicit models behind critiques of the left's shift into identity politics from folks like Chris Trotter, it's a good read.
• Cass Sunstein's 'Economic Constitution of the United States' would also hit the syllabus. I've viewed the Public Finance Act and Reserve Bank Act as being part of New Zealand's economic constitution. Sunstein here makes the case around the rules around regulation and regulatory impact assessment.

Afternoon roundup

The closing of the tabs...

• Transport is in the ETS. Therefore, bus networks do not need decarbonisation strategies. Councils can just assess the all-up costs of different options - with a measure for the cost of particulate matter pollution in places that are less windy than Wellington. I don't know why NZTA has funded research to models weighing up 'different bus decarbonisation strategies'. 


• Canterbury's Mike Grimshaw on the fundamental underlying problem with NZ's universities.


• Ryan Bourne on the War on Prices


• The CFTC had been the safe harbour that let the IEM run. They've since been taken over by Vogons. 

Afternoon roundup

A closing of some of the tabs

First, a set from closing a pile of the week's accumulated stories from the Stuff papers. I wonder whether the people who complain about the absence of real journalism bother reading what The Post and Sunday Star Times have been putting out lately. 

• National's 'tax relief' won't be a tax cut "because the only real cut is a spending cut, anything else is just rearranging who pays what and in which generation."
• "If Health New Zealand can't find doctors, his iwi will." Some of the social services already being provided by Ngāti Toa.
• Andrea Vance asks "How did the cost of moving two schools blow out to more than $400m?"
• Promising work on methane vaccines for cows. Including great context from Dave Frame. [And here's Dave Frame and Adrian Macey over at Business Desk on methane]
• A path from John Birch through to anti-fluoride activism in NZ that runs through ZAP - a group I'd not heard of for at least a decade. Just great stuff from Charlie Mitchell here. 
• Poor response rates in the 2023 Census, and speculation that it might be the last census as we know censuses. 
• This one is just beautifully written. Joe Bennett on a walk up a hill.

  There’s a lot to be said for being a cattle beast. You live with friends. Your food is all about you. You own nothing but an ear tag. And castration frees you from the main source of worry and expense. Admittedly you make one bad journey in the end, but you don’t see it coming, and your mates go with you. And you’re spared the horrors of old age.

And the rest of the tabs. Or some of the rest. I'm drowning here but the computer needs to be rebooted.... 

• One hypothesis on why Google Search doesn't work as well as it once did.
• Another climate stress test, another finding of zero systemic risk justifying RBNZ's continued prudential excursions into climate issues. Unless prudential reg now is meant not to guard against systemic risk and instead starts from assuming that bank directors are idiots and that bank shareholders need to be protected against bad decisions.
• NZ's NPS-UD doesn't go hard enough. British Columbia's enabling apartments up to 20 stories near transit stations. 
• A new (to me anyway) metastudy on workforce diversity. Effects are significant and positive, "but insubstantial."
• "If the government believes making it more difficult to recruit offshore is going to get 50,000 people off the dole they are as deluded as all those who came before them who wanted to believe the same thing. I get the politics. I don't get the economics."
• RBNZ now investigating whether we should have a central bank digital currency.
• The Government really ought to push ahead with the Rule of Two for Medsafe Approvals. It would unlock access to RSV vaccines. Come on......
• Taiwan wants NZ to do more in supporting anti-authoritarianism. I wonder whether we ought to be doing more in supporting scholarships for promising students from the Islands to study in NZ.
• After my Insights column on the Christchurch Cathedral cost-benefit assessment, a reader pointed us to the business case for a major Tauranga city redevelopment project. I'd hope that, if central government is putting money into this, it pushed hard on checking whether the increases in tourism are plausible (and net national rather than within-country diversion). And whatever arguments one wants to have about appropriate discount rates for social projects as compared to infrastructure projects, expect infrastructure spending (like museums) to be portrayed as social investment where the lower discount rate allows a higher NPV for purported benefits. Bit of a Lil Lisa's Slurry problem here. 
  
  
  

Afternoon roundup

The afternoon's worthies:

• Immigration restrictions on spousal work rights are dangerous.
• 28 months jail for tobacco smuggling
• Pseudoephedrine is legal. Now we just have to wait for pharmacies to stock it.
• Really neat stuff on NZ board directors. 
• When Wisconsin school districts got to decide how to pay their teachers, shifting to flexible pay "raised salaries of high-quality teachers, increased teacher quality (due to the arrival of high-quality teachers from other districts and increased effort), and improved student achievement." HT: John Dickson.
• RBNZ's estimates of the neutral interest rate
• Rocket Lab's increasing success in landing US DoD contracts. 
• Ikea is spending just over $400 million to open its NZ shop.

Afternoon roundup

More bits as I clear through the tabs. 

• Kevin Rudd's view on south Pacific security.
• 20,000 hard refusals on the 2023 census, up from 6000 in 2018.
• Andrew Heaton talks with Zach Weinersmith about space settlements.
• General Practitioners really ought to be allowed to prescribe for ADD/ADHD. 
• TVNZ in financial trouble, but still doesn't offer a subscription-version of its streaming offering for those who can't abide the ads. 
• The demographics of Parliament
• Climate Commission recognising potential for carbon sequestration through reinjection in geothermal wells. Excellent. 
• The Gods of the Copybook Headings always slouch up to explain it once more. They've been explaining it in education system results. Good that we're starting to recognise it. 
• If there's a right to be protected from the effects of climate change...
• Infrastructure Commission doesn't mince words on Auckland light rail. 

Morning roundup

The tabs did accumulate. A couple of worthies. 

• There will be no bailouts of local councils that neglected their pipes. Good. 
• Me, over in Newsroom, reminding everyone of the mess Canada made by trying to turn Facebook into a media funding entity. It's now sounding like National, who had been very sceptical about the proposal during the election campaign, are warming to the darned thing. Pretty disappointing if so.
• Like I told y'all last year, it was always pretty obvious what National's plan for council water reform would be. It would be based on Castalia's work with Communities for Local Democracy. Like they said it would be.  
• Canada's Conservative Party pandering to loonies on the right. 
• Alison Andrew's talk at the Waikato Economics Forum was excellent. She's CE of Transpower. Transpower just works in ways that council water just doesn't. Consider the incentives both face. Transpower is self-funding through charges on users of its transmission lines, under standard utilities regulation that allows them a return on their capital. Council water, well, no. But that doesn't meant there aren't problems for Transpower. I hope that the proposed fast-track consenting solves some of this mess.

Afternoon roundup

Sure doesn't take long for the tabs to pile up after summer break.

Some worthies:

• CPI y/y now at 4.7%, q/q 0.5%. Remember that the y/y figures will be comparing current CPI, where fuel has full excise, with Dec quarter 2022, when fuel had a substantial excise discount. Treasury had figured that removing excise had meant something like a half percentage point effect on y/y CPI figures when Labour put in the discount; should be roughly the same in reverse currently. So y/y is overstated relative to actual inflation. It's still over the top of the target band. But the quarterly result is encouraging: annualising 0.5% gets you a titch over 2%. 
• While talking about CPI, remember that normal drill has annual inflation adjustments to tobacco excise from the accumulated prior-year inflation. And that would feed through into the subsequent year CPI figures. RNZ says the government may pause the CPI increases to tobacco excise. If you think that tobacco excise is set at a level commensurate with social cost, then you'd want the real value of excise to not be affected by inflation. If you, like me, think that excise is multiples of actual social cost while incredibly punitive for lower-income smoking households, then you'd be happy with holding it and happier with reducing it explicitly. 
• The Government Economics Network is surveying government-employed economists and non-economists about what training they might be needing. I think they need a lot more background in what the mainstream consensus actually is, rather than a pile of heterodox conference keynotes. There's an important place for heterodox thinking: in the academic economics departments, which then sort out which bits have to be incorporated into the academic mainstream. 
• GEN's survey of Ministry chief economists was interesting though. They note difficulty in matching market rates for economists, which can't be good for the quality of economic policy advice. I liked this bit: "Economics is not the only area where the prize for being good at something is to be promoted to another job with less of the thing one was promoted for and more meetings. Nevertheless, respondents said that this seemed to be more apparent in economics than general policy roles."
• Farmers Weekly on some of the issues for NZ with the pirates/terrorists having closed the Red Sea. BusinessDesk notes a $1600/container surcharge because of it. That NZ has sent six (6) NZDF staff to help reopen that route has melted some peoples' brains. 
• Walking around town, I notice a whole lot of leaks that were around before we left on summer holiday are still there, some worsening. The one on Tinakore Road outside the daycare is going to wreck the road where it's been bubbling out for months. Wellington Water is also not proving itself particularly competent: a pressure valve installation led to a new leak, repeatedly reported by residents, culminating in an explosion with trees knocked over and footpath wrecked. Wellington's power lines are owned by a private company; they're fine....
• I hadn't seen this before. App that traces out how people commute to and from various suburbs, from Census 2018. 
• We live in an age of wonders.
• I endorse every one of the City for People's recommendations for the Wellington district plan. Would go further, but each of these is good. 

Afternoon roundup

The tabs!

• “Is it unfair on everybody else that has paid for that road and doesn't use it? I mean, this equity stuff's bollocks, this is about traffic. ...Consultation’s bollocks as well.” Mayor Brown ain't wrong.
• Predictions that Labour and Te Pati Maori will strike a deal where TPM seeks only the electorate votes in Maori districts and Labour seeks only the party vote in those districts. Biggest question is why MMP has avoided these kinds of rorts so far. They're the obvious play. 
• Good time to be a liquidator.
• 35 kilograms seems like a lot of cocaine to seize in one go for a country of 5m people. Are there reasonable measures of demand elasticity? One could perhaps work out the size of the market based on price movement. If the price doesn't move much, either the market is huge or suppliers are able to quickly plug even a 35kg hole. If it moves a lot and stays high for a long time, less so.
• My normal drill on carbon forests and biodiversity is that if you want more biodiversity, don't screw up the ETS accounting - use a separate policy instrument. But if this is right, then biodiverse forests sequester more carbon. And if it also applies to NZ forests, then making sure the settings accurately reflected sequestration would encourage greater biodiversity. 
• Don't envy Shane Reti this hospital pass. The health system is not in good shape. 
• Works in Progress on Upzoning NZ
• Maybe post-prison half-way houses should be next door to judges' primary residences. Skin in the game and all that.
• NZ needs a dedicated agency whose only task is infectious disease. Indeed.
• Andrew Norton on Australian attempts to centrally plan higher ed.
• Why We Need Taiwan.
• Mercatus on cutting zoning down to size. Tons of good stuff in here on problems with single-family zoning. 
• Good News! New Zealand is at less of a competitive disadvantage relative to Australia! Bad news: it's because they dropped by more than we did.

Afternoon roundup

The tabs!

• Universities continue to be very quick to cancel events. 
• NZ Pharmacists warn that if the $5 co-pay on prescriptions returns, customers might start using Chemist Warehouse again rather than community pharmacies. 
• David Harvey argues for a licensing regime instead of the Fair Digital News Bargaining Bill. I don't think it'll work either. If the fee is high enough to save the media, the platforms would probably block news links altogether. Just let the Bill die at committee.
• Reasonable Covid wave coming through; your reminder of what to do.
• Which cuisine will reign supreme? All of them, thanks to globalisation. 
• Consumer NZ wants to turn audiology into a government-enforced cartel. That outfit's becoming increasingly reliable as a "do the opposite of whatever they're on about" signal. 

Morning roundup

A closing of the browser tabs:

• The Economist's write-up of Barcelona's new Museum of Prohibited Art. The museum's website is here. 
• Europe considering pricing agricultural emissions.
• Bill Gates on some of the climate tech in the pipeline.
• Cass Sunstein on goods that people buy but wish did not exist. Fun as a logical exercise - this class of goods could exist in this way. But banning them would just push status-seeking onto other margins. Other margins can be worse. And what if there's an additional class of goods: ones that people loudly claim they wish didn't exist, but secretly enjoy? In that case, could you ever tell which ought to be banned?
• Stephen Jennings's Conversation with Tyler. Great stuff on building new cities in Africa, and a gloomy bit about New Zealand. 
• What happens when central government tries to centrally plan daycare. Maybe Stephen Jennings is right to be pessimistic about the place. 

Morning roundup

The closing of the tabs....

• Free speech used to be a US left-wing value. On American campuses, only conservative students would support allowing a controversial speaker they disagreed with to speak on campus. This is very bad. 
• There's some support for free-speech on the NZ left, mostly Chris Trotter and Josie Pagani and Bryce Edwards. The rest pretends that free speech is some American neoliberal imposition and that we need nuanced approaches in which enlightened Wellingtoneans (themselves) would get to tell everyone else what speech is allowed. I wish we had better data on broader preferences.  
• The growth of the public sector over the past six years.
• The US National Institute of Justice rated the South Dakota 24/7 sobriety project as promising. Their whole database is likely useful for those keen on approaches that have some evaluation. 
• A $1 increase in US minimum wages is associated with a 0.92 percentage point reduction in percentage of employers offering health insurance and a 1.93 p.p. increase in prevalence of plans with deductibles. Always remember that total compensation bundles are more than just wages, and that squeezing one element of that bundle may affect the others. 
• The Paul Ramsay Foundation thinks Evidence Institutes, which trawl the lit [like the US National Institute of Justice, above] are a good idea. 
• Oh, I'm going to have to come back to this one as a dedicated post or column. Luming Chen's job market paper at UW-Madison. Policy uncertainty around wind energy destroys $5.9 billion in value in the US. 

Morning roundup

The morning's worthies.

• Medsafe allows low-dose CBD over-the-counter. +1 for Medsafe. Unfortunately, no CBD products are here approved and we don't just automatically approve medicines that have been approved by trusted overseas agencies. -50 for NZ.
• Danyl McLauchlan's alt-centrist manifesto, or at least steps toward one. 
• A presidential succession horror story
• A post-mortem on the Gino case. I keep remembering back to my time at Canterbury, and how the administrator appointed as Pro-Vice Chancellor, and the leftists in Accounting, wanted Econ to catch up with the times and start teaching all the "people aren't rational" stuff that's since fallen apart in replication or was downright fraud. 
• Wellington has more than enough problems of its own without central government funded busibodies trying to close all the bars. 
• Take a bow, Australia, Canada, Willie Jackson - and compatriots. Y'all have made news too much of a hassle to be worth the trivial amounts of revenue associated with linking to news. 
• Will be interesting to see what the next Wellington LTP looks like. Council could avoid the scenario that Castalia has put up, or at least some of it. If they're spending hundreds of millions on Town Hall, they could decide from day one just to demolish the opera house and the Fowler Centre.

Afternoon roundup

Eight browser windows each full of tabs. Something's gotta give.

• Excellent quips from our Treasury Secretary in response to RBNZ pleading for even more money.
• All the BS speech restrictions that apply on election day. 
• I don't get how Brian Albrecht doesn't yet have a syndicated national column in the US. Gold!
• Bits from me and a few others on whether National or Labour is 'better for business'
• My column at Newsroom this week expanded on last week's post on the NIMBY problem. 
• British Columbia's Supreme Court backs the Squamish Nation's push to build a pile of needed apartment towers on Squamish land in Vancouver, batting back NIMBYs. 
• A Commerce Commission that were on its game would be checking into just how the existing cartels have managed to block a new nurses' training school from training new nurses. 
• Excellent piece by Bill Watson on competition policy versus actual competition.
• Interesting ideas from Andrew Body and Simon Jensen on improving prudential bank regulation in NZ. But there's still the bigger question of whether we ought to split monetary from prudential.
• Noah Smith thinks a three-state solution is needed. I can't see how that works while Hamas runs Gaza, but maybe somebody will figure it out.
• "The region's pipes are ageing at a faster rate than they can be fixed." Wellington is such a mess. But I simply don't buy the claim that "Our councils are pushing their ratepayers to the limit in order to fund [Wellington Water]." Our council is set to spend $350m earthquake strengthening a building that could be bulldozed and just built a convention centre and is spending $100m more than necessary on a central library.  
• Queenstown has the country's worst housing shortage. The Infrastructure Commission points out that Queenstown's new plan will enable about 31-149 houses over ten years. Neither National nor Labour are really serious about housing.
• The final chapter in BusinessDesk's excellent series on the state of the NZ public service and the legacy of Peter Hughes. I still think an incoming government should fire Hughes pretty much on day 1 rather than let him see things through to February. 
• Years back we'd been arguing for a variant on city deals. They're in fashion now, with some risk of monkey-paw problems. 

Morning roundup

The morning's clearing of the tabs...

• Price theory is the core of everything that's good in economics. Albrecht and Hendrickson explain the basics. Price theory emphasises exchange and emergent outcomes. Public choice studies politics as exchange. It's fun to think about what would happen if an incoming government required Ministry Chief Economists to pass a test based on workouts in the old Alchian & Allen textbook.  
• Like the idea of government paying a bonus to people for having kids? Robin Hanson has a neat way of doing that. But I doubt that proponents of baby bonuses will like it. 
• This came out a while back but I'd missed it. Surprisingly enough, hydrogen deposits seem to form underground in spots where olivine is prevalent in the presence of heat and water. NZ has a lot of olivine, and heat, and wet. I wonder if anyone's gone looking for hydrogen - geological deposits hadn't previously been thought possible. If we have some, stick a pipe in it to power a boiler and generator above the deposit, and you'd have electricity that generates water rather than CO2. Seems a longshot, but would be pretty sweet.
• Chris Trotter is nostalgic for a joyous left. Excellent piece. 
• This kind of thing pushes electricity toward a global law-of-one-price, doesn't it?
• Henry Thompson on the Industrial Organisation of the Mafia, forthcoming in the JLE.  
  

  This paper uses economic reasoning to analyze the organization of one of the most successful criminal groups in modern U.S. history: La Cosa Nostra (LCN). Drawing on recently declassified FBI reports and a hand-collected dataset, I argue that the costs of violent disputes are key for an economic understanding of LCN’s core institutions. Violent disputes were costly for LCN as they consumed resources to produce and were destructive. However, violent disputes were especially costly to LCN because of its need to keep a low profile. As a member did not bear the full costs of a profile-raising police investigation, each had a perverse incentive to resolve a dispute with violence. Hierarchical firms and a sophisticated court system were LCN’s solution. They gave bosses the authority and incentive to limit violent disputes and to use violence judiciously. LCN’s longevity and success are, in part, a testament to the institutions’ efficacy.

   

Afternoon roundup

The tabs...

• Earthquake strengthening costs on one Wellington performance venue have increased from $90m to $182m and now to $329m (Dom, Herald). We have no clue what strengthening the recently quake-designated Michael Fowler Centre and Opera House might cost. Would it be crazy to expect a billion dollars across all three? After $100m more than necessary on a library? All for a town of about 200,000 people where the water pipes are a century-old collapsing mess? It's a good thing Wellington's pretty...
• Mothers of underweight babies below a cut-off get substantial US government support; those just above the cut-off don't. Run the RDD and find no effects of funding on outcomes. 
• NZ's National Party promises non-finance spending two percentage points of GDP higher than Ardern promised in the 2019 Wellbeing Budget. 
• Devastating New Yorker piece on the Ariely / Gino mess. Harvard's Business School is not a serious place. 
• Admin staff at the Auckland Uni law school are substantially happier than faculty. I keep wondering when somebody might set up a union that represents only academic staff. 
• Superb BusinessDesk piece on Sean Colgan, who backed Rako in its fight with the Ministry of Health. And has leant David Seymour a plan for the election campaign. 
• My piece in this past weekend's Stuff papers covers two recent NBER working papers on zero-sum thinking. 
• California's math curriculum is nuts. Unfortunately, this kind of nuttiness is also infecting New Zealand.
• A lot of US voters are confused about whether Robert F Kennedy Jr is Bobby Kennedy. They identify the picture of Bobby Kennedy from the 1950s, the father of Robert F Kennedy Jr, as being Robert F Kennedy Jr. He's aged remarkably well if so; the father would be turning 98 later this year. Every time you learn a little bit more about voters, just be amazed that the world isn't even worse. 
• For six years, NZ had a government that expressed commitment to wellbeing as its highest goal, and yet this. 
• So Sanitarium ran into some supply issues and cut supply to The Warehouse before either Foodstuffs or Woolworths. Which seems more plausible: that the whole thing is a stitch-up by the big supermarkets to get Sanitarium to cut out a low-price potential competitor, with a new grocery regulator watching? Or that the big supermarkets have longstanding contracts where they pay a bit more to have clauses providing greater security of supply? I'd bet on the latter, but nobody else seems to have considered that possibility.

Afternoon roundup

The tabs. There are too many.

• Dan Brunskill asks 20 economists how they'd define recession. A bunch of us pointed to how NBER does things. 
• Believing that recycling does much of anything to reduce GHG emissions is wrong and gets you laughed at. Believing that reducing your consumption of things covered by the ETS will reduce GHG emissions is also wrong, but generally gets you plaudits. 
• A paranoid person might start to think that government-funded media goes on crusades to name and pillory pseudonymous critics of the government who do not share their cultural views. 
• The last $5b of the Covid fund was blown on a bunch of populist vote-buying exercises. Good luck getting cross-party consensus to take on just-in-case debt in the next crisis. Labour has really poisoned this well. It is very bad if you think that future governments need to be able to do this. 
• Harvard should protect whistleblowers.
• Michael Gordon has a substack. And he provides a helpful reminder about SNZ's work trying to figure out why the jobseeker numbers are so out of whack when compared to the unemployment figures. 
• Susan Edmunds checks on CTU Craig Renney's claims that the economy's doing great. I pointed to a couple cautions, but also one area where he might have understated things: employment rates were at or near historic highs before Covid hit. 
• Oliver Lewis points to the ways that National's housing policies will likely fail. I still wish National and Labour could have maintained consensus on MDRS by setting a price target for exemptions. 
• There were a lot of appropriate condemnations of poor forestry practice leading to bad outcomes during the recent floods. And a lot of that turned into the usual "it's all neoliberalism's fault" nonsense. Anyway, here's Queenstown Council doing exactly the same thing, causing similar problems.
• I still think the funniest chaos outcome for the election would be Labour winning, but only because it loses enough party votes to the Greens that it gets a substantial overhang from its electorate seats. One can engineer scenarios where National and ACT get 51% of the vote and still lose. It's not entirely plausible, but it would make for a chaotic election night. Here's Greg O'Connor stumping for the electorate vote.
• Remember how I wanted a public health agency laser-focused on contagious disease so it wouldn't just shift back to its usual BS? Pandemic's still going, and they're already back on their usual nonsense. 
• Ngāi Te Rangi is importing houses from the US to build here. I still think that iwi should declare themselves to be their own consenting authorities and tell naysayers to sue them if they don't like it. If council makes it tough for iwi to build houses on their own land...
• BusinessDesk has a series on cost blowouts on infrastructure. On average infrastructure costs have been 23% over their initial budgets. The paper's really worth the sub.